Pathological Voice Detection with Nkululeko

I tried to add a recipe to Nkululeko for pathological voice detection using the Saarbrueken Voice Database (SVD, the dataset currently perhaps cannot be downloaded due to a server problem). Using Nkululeko is easy; I just need two working days (with a lot of play and others) to process the data and get the initial result. The evaluation was mainly measured with F1-Score (Macro). The initial result is an F1-score of 71% obtained using open smile ('os') and SVM without any customization.

On the third day, I made some modifications, but I am still using the 'os' feature (so I don't need to extract the feature again, using the same 'exp' directory to boost my experiments). The best F1 score I achieved was 76% (macro). This time, the modifications were: without feature scaling, feature balancing with smote, and using XGB as a classifier. My goal is to obtain an F1 score of 80% before the end of the fiscal year (March 2025).

Here is the configuration (INI) file and a sample of outputs (terminal).

Configuration file:

[EXP]
root = /tmp/results/
name = exp_os
[DATA]
databases = ['train', 'dev', 'test']
train = ./data/svd/svd_a_train.csv
train.type = csv
train.absolute_path = True
train.split_strategy = train
train.audio_path = /data/SaarbrueckenVoiceDatabase/export_16k
dev = ./data/svd/svd_a_dev.csv
dev.type = csv
dev.absolute_path = True
dev.split_strategy = train
dev.audio_path = /data/SaarbrueckenVoiceDatabase/export_16k
test = ./data/svd/svd_a_test.csv
test.type = csv
test.absolute_path = True
test.split_strategy = test
test.audio_path = /data/SaarbrueckenVoiceDatabase/export_16k
target = label
; no_reuse = True
; labels = ['angry', 'calm', 'sad']
; get the number of classes from the target column automatically
[FEATS]
; type = ['wav2vec2']
; type = ['hubert-large-ll60k']
; type = []
type = ['os']
; scale = standard
balancing = smote
; no_reuse = True
[MODEL]
type = xgb

Outputs:

$ python3 -m nkululeko.nkululeko --config exp_svd/exp_os.ini 
DEBUG: nkululeko: running exp_os from config exp_svd/exp_os.ini, nkululeko version 0.88.12
DEBUG: dataset: loading train
DEBUG: dataset: Loaded database train with 1650 samples: got targets: True, got speakers: False (0), got sexes: False, got age: False
DEBUG: dataset: converting to segmented index, this might take a while...
DEBUG: dataset: loading dev
DEBUG: dataset: Loaded database dev with 192 samples: got targets: True, got speakers: False (0), got sexes: False, got age: False
DEBUG: dataset: converting to segmented index, this might take a while...
DEBUG: dataset: loading test
DEBUG: dataset: Loaded database test with 190 samples: got targets: True, got speakers: False (0), got sexes: False, got age: False
DEBUG: dataset: converting to segmented index, this might take a while...
DEBUG: experiment: target: label
DEBUG: experiment: Labels (from database): ['n', 'p']
DEBUG: experiment: loaded databases train,dev,test
DEBUG: experiment: reusing previously stored /tmp/results/exp_os/./store/testdf.csv and /tmp/results/exp_os/./store/traindf.csv
DEBUG: experiment: value for type is not found, using default: dummy
DEBUG: experiment: Categories test (nd.array): ['n' 'p']
DEBUG: experiment: Categories train (nd.array): ['n' 'p']
DEBUG: nkululeko: train shape : (1842, 3), test shape:(190, 3)
DEBUG: featureset: value for n_jobs is not found, using default: 8
DEBUG: featureset: reusing extracted OS features: /tmp/results/exp_os/./store/train_dev_test_os_train.pkl.
DEBUG: featureset: value for n_jobs is not found, using default: 8
DEBUG: featureset: reusing extracted OS features: /tmp/results/exp_os/./store/train_dev_test_os_test.pkl.
DEBUG: experiment: All features: train shape : (1842, 88), test shape:(190, 88)
DEBUG: experiment: scaler: False
DEBUG: runmanager: value for runs is not found, using default: 1
DEBUG: runmanager: run 0 using model xgb
DEBUG: modelrunner: balancing the training features with: smote
DEBUG: modelrunner: balanced with: smote, new size: 2448 (was 1842)
DEBUG: modelrunner: {'n': 1224, 'p': 1224})
DEBUG: model: value for n_jobs is not found, using default: 8
DEBUG: modelrunner: value for epochs is not found, using default: 1
DEBUG: modelrunner: run: 0 epoch: 0: result: test: 0.771 UAR
DEBUG: modelrunner: plotting confusion matrix to train_dev_test_label_xgb_os_balancing-smote_0_000_cnf
DEBUG: reporter: Saved confusion plot to /tmp/results/exp_os/./images/run_0/train_dev_test_label_xgb_os_balancing-smote_0_000_cnf.png
DEBUG: reporter: Best score at epoch: 0, UAR: .77, (+-.704/.828), ACC: .773
DEBUG: reporter: 
               precision    recall  f1-score   support

           n       0.65      0.76      0.70        67
           p       0.86      0.78      0.82       123

    accuracy                           0.77       190
   macro avg       0.76      0.77      0.76       190
weighted avg       0.79      0.77      0.78       190

DEBUG: reporter: labels: ['n', 'p']
DEBUG: reporter: Saved ROC curve to /tmp/results/exp_os/./results/run_0/train_dev_test_label_xgb_os_balancing-smote_0_roc.png
DEBUG: reporter: auc: 0.771, pauc: 0.560 from epoch: 0
DEBUG: reporter: result per class (F1 score): [0.703, 0.817] from epoch: 0
DEBUG: experiment: Done, used 11.065 seconds
DONE

Update 2024/08/30: 

• Using praat + xgb (no scaling, balancing: smote) achieves higher F1-score, i.e.,  78% (macro) and 79% (weighted)
   

A paper was accepted at ACM MM 2024 Workshop

 

I am delightful to show that my paper was accepted at the ACM MM 2024. This was my first ACM paper and was written by myself solely (solo author). Here is an abstract from the screenshot of the paper above.

Abstact

 Automatic social perception recognition is a new task to mimic the measurement of human traits, which was previously done by humans via questionnaires. We evaluated unimodal and multimodal systems to predict agentive and communal traits from the LMU-ELP dataset. We optimized variants of recurrent neural networks from each feature from audio and video data and then fused them to predict the traits. Results on the development set show a consistent trend that multimodal fusion outperforms unimodal systems. The performance-weighted fusion also consistently outperforms mean and maximum fusions. We found two important factors that influence the performance of performance-weighted fusion. These factors are normalization and the number of models.

Once the link of the paper is available in ACM Library, I will put the link here.

Link: XXX.

Behind The Scene and Tips!

I have participating in MuSe challenge (Multimodal Sentiment Analysis Challenge and Workshop) for several years. This challenge, along with other challenges in conference like ICASSP and Interspeech, usually provides baseline program (code) and the respected dataset (e.g., ComParE). From this baseline, we can further analyze, make experiments, and often get new ideas to implement. My idea for that challenge (social perception challenge) is two parts: parameter optimization and multimodal fusion. I implement a lot of ideas (e.g., tuning more than 15 parameters) and some works. Once I get improvement with consistent results/phenomena (science must consistent!), I documented my work and submit a paper. This time, my paper got accepted!

See you in Melbourne, inshallah!